View Single Post
Old 02-25-2010, 02:57 PM   #271
bashi
Avalon Senior Member
 
Join Date: Dec 2009
Posts: 214
Default Re: Steven Greer Interview Discussion

.

Lets come back to the basics: The spoken words of the interview itself and in which context they were spoken:
Greer was ranting about commonly known things until nearly half of the time has passed. Then B&K were getting a bit inpatient and were drilling down. Unfortunately there is no transcript, but here some excepts from the interview:

Greer:”You can`t prove the negative (ETs). One of the evidence we have: We have had never any negative contact”
Kerry:”You can get evidence on both sides of the question…”

(Waoo!! That’s scientific approach by Greer!!!
He should have added:“… which I can remember.”)

K: “But what we don’t want to do is analyse this (galactic) scene, this scenario in these realities that are out there, and say that we have come to a definite statement where we can say: `There are only good ETs`
Now let me tell you why that is dangerous as well: Because what that does is: leave people/humans, and humanity possibly in general, in a vulnerable position, because they are then going around following ET like the piper down whatever road they are taking.”
G:” Unfortunately you haven’t read my books..” (what a discussion-strategy!!)
K:”Actually, I have…”

G:” Interstellar civilisations are not allowed to leave their biosphere until they have become in agreement with..peace.”
K:” That’s an assumption!”
G:” This has been proven!” (his proof comes later..)
K:” No way! Nothing has been proven on this planet at that degree of sophistication.”

Later..

G:” There is a quarantine on this planet until we become peaceful.”
K:” There is a PHILOSPHY that there is a quarantine.”
G: “No, there is!”
K:” Why? Because ET told you? Really lets get down to..”
G:” If you look at what Neil Armstrong said…”
(THAT`S HIS PROOF!!!)
K:” A mind-controlled astronaut, that’s you are talking about! You are giving me a testimony of a mind controlled astronaut as proof!!! (very good counter! )


So, what do we have here:
Greer states that he has nearly 20 years of expertise, comes from well known scientific family/background and has lots of connections. He gives the impression as if an arrogant teacher is talking to a stupid pupil who dares to question fundamental truths. Also he is applying a very good rhetoric tactic: He is turning the table by tasking B&K to proof that there are “bad” ET, while not proving his own point. His discussion-skills made him a formidable opponent and he is able to give an impression as if he is defending his position well, while in reality it boils down to pure rhetorics.
He makes a very definite, fundamental statement and says that quarantine has been proven. That “proof” is more than questionable, as it is already well known that astronauts were “briefed and de-briefed” with mind-control techniques.

But for me the best is:

G:”If there is a civilisation that is here for their own purely selfish interest and have not a shred of altruism or concern for humanity on Earth, these are the beings I want to meet with first. And I said this for years...”

Well, you are waiting for an invitation by malevolent Aliens to let you disclose their existence. You are not getting that for years, and so your logical conclusion is: They are not existing!
This is absolutely hilarious!
Every Mafia-Mob would like to have you, Stephen , as their police-chief!!!

Now, with all of Greer’s acclaimed expertise, he is posting these pictures as a proof of direct ET contact:

http://www.cseti.org/reports/joshuatree09pictures.htm

This is now getting seriously pathologic.
Conclusion: I don’t want to man-hunt him down, but I think something very serious has happened to Greer, and it was not a benevolent contact. That of course has never happened, because he can’t remember it.

Advise to Greer: Read the “Mars Records” and get a good therapy!


.
bashi is offline   Reply With Quote